Gizmosmith

Naming things and "ImportError: No module named msg"

I’m using ROS at school for a project. Part of the project is to detect someone’s hand with a camera, so I’m just looking for a patch of “skin colored*” pixels. ROS organizes software as packages, with nodes in them, and messages that the nodes use to communicate with each other.

For my system, I had a package called “hand_detector” with a source file called “hand_detector.py” and a message type called “hand”. ROS generates the messages, which I then import into my python code with the line:

from hand_detector.msg import *

This gets me the error message: “ImportError: No module named msg”

The reason for this is that python searches the same directory as the executing script for imports before it goes looking anywhere else. Since the file hand_detector.py is the executing script, and is naturally in the directory with itself, python finds it there, imports it into itself, and then tries to find a module called “msg” within hand_detector.py. There’s no .msg in there, so I get the error.

The moral of the story here is don’t name your package and the script in it the same thing. Once I converted the script to just “detector.py”, the problem went away.

*I’m somewhat concerned that I wrote a “white people detector”, as it’s really just thresholding the H part of the HSV color space and counting pixels. Other color spaces may be better for this, but this doesn’t have to be perfect. I just don’t want the robot to be a dick to black people.